Donate

Categories

Advert

XHTML

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional

Noise Canceling Headphones

My patience with the noise of airlines has run out, on my trip from AU to US I didn’t get any sleep due to the cramped seat and the noise of the plane. While I can’t do anything about the cramped seat without spending a lot of money it seems that I can do something about the noise with moderate expense.

I’ve been researching Noise Canceling Headphones [1]. The principle of such devices is that they have a microphone on the outside and a speaker on the inside to generate sound that is 180 degrees out of phase which will then almost cancel out the ambient noise. Apparently such devices are very effective for low frequencies but less effective for high frequencies. High frequencies are more easily blocked by sound insulation, so the ideal seems to be “around the ear” headphones with lots of padding to passively stop noise with active noise canceling to deal with the lower frequencies.

So I’m now planning on buying a set of headphones before I leave the US.

Choice Magazine (an Australian independent product review organisation) published a review of noise canceling headphones in 2007, it has some interesting information but is not suitable for buying advice today [2]. Choice gave the best results to the Jabra C820s which had just gone out of production when they published the review and by now could only be bought on eBay. The Jabra had an active cancellation of 14.3dB and a passive cancellation of 8.3dB. The best active cancellation of all the reviewed products was 19.5dB for the Bose QuietComfort 3 – which incidentally only had a passive cancellation of 4.8dB. Both the Bose and Jabra products got good reviews in a mailing list discussion. It’s a pity that Jabra is now only manufacturing products for call centers.

I am not considering the headphones that go on top of the ears, they will inherently give less passive protection due to the design and they will annoy me. I am also not considering the ear-buds because I don’t like putting things in my ears. I will note that there are some very positive reviews of some of the ear-bud devices. The Etymotic Research devices get very good reviews and are apparently on sale at reasonable prices in Apple stores (among other places) [3]. Anyone who wants noise-canceling headphones and disagrees with me about the desirability of ear-bud type devices should probably consider them.

The Bose QuietComfort 15 is selling for $300 (NB for this post all prices will be in US dollars) [4]. It has microphones both inside and outside the ear cup to allow better detection of ambient sound. A single AAA battery is supposed to last 35 hours, it has a detachable audio cable (for use in just blocking noise), and comes with an airline adapter (for the two-port airline sockets). It does require being turned on to listen to audio, some headphones allow you to turn off the noise canceling feature to listen to music without a battery – this doesn’t matter for my planned use. They have a volume switch (low and high settings) to cope with airlines that set the volume too high. They are specifically designed for passengers in commercial jet aircraft. Surprisingly the Bose web site doesn’t mention the number of dB of audio protection and none of the reviews I have read have mentioned it either.

The store Brookstone was recommended, they have some unbranded noise canceling headphones, but as they are on the ear and more expensive than comparable Sony products ($130 vs $100) I eliminated them quickly.

Sony has a good range of noise-canceling headphones [5]. They have ear-buds starting at $90 and on-ear headphones for as little as $50. They have two models of over the ear headphones that are advertised at $200 and $400. The MDR-NC60 costs $200 and reduces noise by 12dB at 200Hz while the MDR-NC500D costs $400 and reduces noise by 20dB at 160Hz. I don’t know why they didn’t measure both headphones at the same frequency or give any information on passive sound insulation. They state that the MDR-NC500D was voted as being better than the Bose QC2 and QC3 but made no such claim about the MDR-NC60 – presumably the older Bose devices were rated as better than the MDR-NC60, and I have to wonder about how the Bose QC15 would compare to the MDR-NC500D. The MDR-NC500D has an internal Lithium-Ion battery that lasts 16 hours and can take a pair of AA batteries as well for a total of 28 hours.

The Sennheiser PXC 350 claims up to 32dB of passive attenuation and up to 18dB of active noise compensation [6]. Their claims about NoiseGuard (TM) cause me to lack confidence in their products. The PXC 350 is advertised at $330 and the reviews that I have read suggest that the Bose might be a better product. Sennheiser also has PXC 450 which offers 23dB of active noise compensation and costs $450. I am not going to pay $450 for headphones.

It seems that the choice for over the ear noise canceling headphones comes down to the Sony MDR-NC60 at $200 and the Bose QuietComfort 15 at $300. I have the impression that the Bose product is better, but whether it is $100 better is the question. Also while I haven’t forgiven Sony for Rootkitting their customers [7], this is not going to prevent me from buying the headphones that best suit my needs.

Does anyone have any suggestions? Did I miss a good brand that I should be considering? Does Sennheiser have some redeeming features that I missed?

12 comments to Noise Canceling Headphones

  • Yea, you missed the Nokia BH-905 which is BOTH Bluetooth and wired and about $200 on Buy.com right now: . Some specs. are here: . It has 8 noise cancelling microphones with 25 hours of operation in Bluetooth mode and 40 hours in wired mode. Also, it has two voice microphones that use centre-field-division DSP to capture only your voice for voice calls. I have found people that have used it with PulseAudio without problems. Supposedly, they allow two connections so you can be listening to music on your laptop, have a call come in on your phone, have it send the Pause/Play signal via AVRCP to the laptop music player, and then answer the call, and when the call is done, the music resumes. I haven’t confirmed this all works with Linux, yet.

    I should be getting mine in the mail this weekend. Reviews are very good.

  • etbe

    http://images.google.com/images?q=BH-905

    According to a Google image search that appears to be an on-ear headset which unfortunately isn’t going to suit my needs. But thanks for the review, I’m sure that some readers of my blog will find it useful, Nokia is known for producing high quality devices. If I was after an on-ear headset then I would definitely consider Nokia!

  • Sennheiser usually is the better choice, not sure about the specific models here, but I would recommend looking for some tests that test actual audio quality (audiophile tests) and look at the frequency response and impedance values in the specification. And also – look for deals on eBay and online stores. You should be able to easily find the PXC 350 for less than 200$.

  • Toby

    Be aware that some Bose models (the newer on-ear for sure) don’t work at all when the batteries are out, not only the noice cancelling – you can’t even listen to music.

    I’m planning to buy Aurvana X-Fi Headphones from Creative, the only bad thing I’ve heard about them is that they leak some when playing loud music :)

    http://en.europe.creative.com/products/product.asp?category=437&subcategory=439&product=16975&listby=

  • There is only one forum you need: head-fi.org
    Any information you might want is there.
    The short version is that you don’t need active noise canceling. Passive in-ear monitors with custom tips such as Comply Foams or triple-flanged ones are already efficient enough to get silence.
    Also, around the hear headphones with significant padding can get very hot and sweaty inside.

  • How about Audio Technica ATH-ANC7? It has pretty good reviews, and I had a customer giving good feedback for it.

  • etbe

    http://www.cnbc.com/id/34256635/

    The above article has an interesting review of the Bose QC 15. It seems that some people experience some discomfort from the active noise cancellation and Bose has a 30 day return policy for them.

    Aigars: Thanks for the suggestion, one thing to note is that I am not looking for audiophile information. In terms of music quality I was happy with using RF to play music from my iRiver in my car. My main aim here is not good music quality but an absence of annoying noise.

    Toby: 20dB of noise reduction sounds good, but E250!!!

    Obey: Thanks for the suggestion, but I find that forums tend not to be very useful to outsiders. Also I have received other suggestions of in-ear monitors. Some people report great success, but such things annoy me and I can’t use them. I would much rather have hot ears!

    E S Lim: The Audio-Technica.com site is designed for Flash, and when you don’t have Flash it demands the use of cookies before showing me any information on their products. Such a poor web site makes me hesitant to buy any technology products from them.

  • Mitch

    Back in 2000 I visited the US, and a friend gave me a try of his noise canceling headphones. Wow. I know this sounds silly but putting them on made the world disappear. I believe they were Maxell, but I’m not sure about that. From memory they weren’t particularly bulky, looking not dissimilar in format to the Bose pair featured at the top of that Choice article. I was told at the time that they were about US$80. Very affordable.

    A few weeks later (and back in Australia) I wanted to buy a NCH for myself. Since I didn’t record either the brand or the model, I wasn’t able to buy the pair I tried. Instead I bought a Sony MDR-NC20 ex USA, which looks similar in format to the Sennheiser PXC350 you mentioned, for about US$250. I figured good brand plus paying enough must equal decent performance.

    I’m still kicking myself. While the Sony I got cancels noise, and is reasonable to play music, its performance in both areas was and is just plain ordinary. No WOW factor whatsoever on either front.

    I clearly remember being shocked by the pair I tried. Did I mention the bit about kicking myself?

  • Mitch

    Just done some reading of NCH reviews on Amazon, and it’s reminded me of two other things about the Sony MDR-NC20. Pro: Turning on the NC lifts the bass noticeably. Con: Slight low frequency hiss always reminds you that you have them on. The first pair I tried were absolutely silent.

    In designing telephone system, we sometimes deliberately introduce a little noise, otherwise the end user might think the connection has been lost:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comfort_noise

    That’s what wearing the Sony (well, that particular model) reminds me of.

  • This internet site is really quite good, but for some reason it does not display properly when trying to view on my Nintendo Wii. If it helps, the console uses the Opera browser and am impelled to using the console for accessing the Net whilst my PC is away being fixed.

  • I actually find Sennheiser PXC 450 NoiseGard Active Noise-Canceling Headphones better suited for me, but thats just me